Apartments in Algoma for Rent

"We enjoyed our stay here! The apartment was very clean. Located in a quiet neighborhood. Close to stores and shops. We would highly recommend this place and would stay here again if we come back to Sturgeon Bay in the future."

"We really enjoyed our stay here. It was exactly as described and in a great location."

"This property is fantastic. It’s clean, quiet and has several amenities. Very nice old historic home which we absolutely loved. Property owners were extremely easy to work with and responded very fast. They even checked on us to see how things were going and if we needed anything. Will definitely stay here again."

"Great location, nice cabin charm."

"My friend and I stayed for a fishing tournament. Great spot for up to two boats. Any more and parking would get tricky. Super nice people on a very nice property."

"Th rental was a gift for my daughter and her fiancé. They had a blast, said the place was adorable. Did quite a bit of hiking and really enjoyed the area."

"I booked this property for an off-season excursion to Sturgeon Bay for a mother-daughter weekend. The location cannot be beat for easy-access to downtown Sturgeon Bay and the rest of the peninsula. The cottage was decorated so perfectly, all of the expected amenities were provided, and it was really nice having a designated parking spot. Loved this property!"

"My husband and I stayed here while ice fishing in the area. It was very cute and cozy. It had everything we needed for our stay and was very close to all the local places to visit!"

"We liked the vintage feel of the apartment very much. Despite good instructions, getting into the apartment/parking was a bit confusing, albeit it was at night and dark. But we found our way and loved the location downtown near everything!"

"Really cute layout of apartment and they have everything you need. Will stay there again next time I’m on the Door."

"Perfect location to all of the great shops and restaurants."

"It’s a lower level walkout apartment. The one bedroom has a great mattress. Slept like a baby. There is an open concept with a small kitchen, table and chairs, a sitting area with YV that has ROKU. WiFi. Out door spaces to sit and enjoy. Bathroom with shower and a 2nd bed at the other end of open area. The driveway is a little hard to see but that adds to the beautiful setting. Property manager was friendly and helpful. A nice clean and comfortable place. Loved it!"

"Unit was spotless and gorgeous! Host was easily accessible and very friendly. Would definitely rent again."

"The house was as listed and Lauri (and her dogs) were very nice and always responsive. We always appreciate a place that allows us to bring our dogs on our trips!"

"The apartment is furnished with top notch furniture. It all looks brand new. The building is clean and neat. Ive stayd at a few differnt VRBOs and I can honestly say the managers are the best I've ever dealt with. They were very responsive (usually within minutes) to any concern. Its a great place to go to get away for a weekend or for a longer stay."

"We enjoyed our stay. It is a very nice location and a beautiful time of year to visit Door Count."

"We ended up having a great time. The kids loved fishing and hanging out by the small beach. The host was amazing too made us feel welcome. Highly recommended!"

"Nicely updated upstairs rental, with a nice view of the bay. Checkin was great- the owner reached out via text and email with photos and instructions for checkin. The property was clean, and there was outdoor furniture to enjoy the fall views (and morning coffee). There were lots of snacks that the owner made available, and also games. Laundry detergent and dishwasher tabs were also onhand. I would recommend and stay again."

"Very well kept and loved our stay."

"The 70s style was entertaining during our stay, and it had everything we needed. What stands out about this place is the location. It had a nice view of the lake, and everywhere we wanted to check out in town was within a few blocks."

"Enjoyed our time in this cottage. Everything was as described in listing. Secluded location, but just a short drive to Sturgeon Bay."

"Beautiful place"

"My husband and I had a fantastic 4-day, 3-night stay at this charming lakefront retreat in Algoma during the off-season. The 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom vacation rental home exceeded my expectations in many ways. The location is ideal for those who enjoy fishing, with access to one of the state's largest charter fishing fleets. It's a perfect angler's retreat. The property boasts spacious land and even features a game room stocked with board games, ensuring there's no shortage of fun activities. The...