Search Youngstown Cottages

"We loved the cottage!! It was so cute! I was just a little confused about where it was located, I didn’t realize it wasn’t right on the water but very close."

"Great location for the fisherman. Driveway easily fits two trailers with boats. Fish cleaning station is excellent. Has all the amenities you need. Beds are very comfortable and kitchen is super."

"Our 2 families with 5 teenagers loved this cozy cottage! It was the perfect central location as we spent a long weekend hiking and disc golfing around Ohio. The back yard and patio would have been perfect if it were a little warmer! Just what we needed!"

"Easy to get to, very very clean, directions easy to understand, pride in ownership, beautiful flat lake shore. Everything was in working order, handicap shower was nice, nicely decorated with lake cabin feel."

"Great house with fenced in yard we enjoued our stay. Would stay again."

"Great cottage for weekend wedding on the lake !"

"All was good. No complaints 😊"

"Very relaxing, quiet vacation."

"We enjoyed relaxing at the cute cozy cottage. We were in town to go to the Harmony Christmas Festival. It was nice to hang out at the cottage after our day out. We saw deer every morning and enjoyed the beautiful sunrises. Dinner at Shakespeare’s Restaurant was excellent and such a unique experience."

"Everything was amazing"

"Very nice property with all the amenities. Close proximity to the lake. We hope to return in warmer weather and take advantage of the water and recreational activities. Christine made sure to have a waiver available however we decided not to use canoe or bikes. Clean cozy cottage"

"Property listings and photos, on very few occasions, represent a rental for it's strengths or weaknesses. What I can tell you is that this property is far better than any picture can depict. I write zero reviews, but I was compelled to write this one, not only praising the rental itself, but also the owner/manager, Jennifer. The layout and cleanliness of this camp is unrivaled to any I've ever been in at Pymatuning. I took my brothers-in-law and uncle up to fish for 3 days, and this camp had it...

"We had a great experience at the cottage. The cottage was very clean and the hot tibb was amazing. We would definitely stay here again in the future."

"We had a great experience. Thank you!"

"The house has had several updates. The kitchen is not one of them. There was evidence of pest control and mice. Dont leave food out. The view in the morning is beautiful in a wooded area. Had a 2 night stay Dec 2023."

"Great spot, perfect location, will definitely stay again."

"I would recommend this house if you want to enjoy the Pymatuning lake area."

"Was only there to sleep. Clean and cozy for a night."

"The house was perfect for our stay for the OAC wrestling tournament. Close enough to the Covelli Center that it was super convenient. The host was so responsive and friendly. We are already planning on booking with her again next year!"

"Maggie was an amazing host. It was a beautiful and peaceful place. Definitely want to go back."