We loved our stay. We went at the beginning of April and it was very quiet in the area. It takes about 15 min to get anywhere to eat, but we enjoyed driving around the area on the twisty roads. Its very pretty - although the trees were still empty, but that made for better site-lines to the lake.
The house was super clean and very well stocked. The kitchen even had 2 crockpots. bonus! I love that they gave us extra toilet paper and paper towel plus laundry and dish detergent. We've been to other rentals that have next to no supplies.
Comfortable mattresses too. There are a lot of stairs, so if you have anyone in your crew that has trouble with stairs, be aware. That seems to be true with most of the houses in that area. It didn't bother us at all.
I would definitely recommend this property. The owners were responsive and gave us great recommendations! We rented a boat from Bombay - half-off prices until May 1. Staff at Bombay was very nice and helpful!